Experimental Design · Lesson 1 of 2
Planning Investigations
Change the independent variable, measure the dependent variable and keep relevant control variables constant. Use a clear repeatable method, a suitable range and repeated measurements. Familiar contexts include tracing rays with optics pins, testing transparent, translucent and opaque materials, and recording a cooling curve.
By the end, you can
- Independent variable.
- Dependent variable.
- Control variables.
- Select suitable apparatus.
- Describe a repeatable procedure.
- Explain how to improve reliability and validity.
- Identify apparatus from diagrams or descriptions, and draw, complete and label diagrams of apparatus.
- Trace rays through rectangular and semicircular blocks using optics pins.
- Investigate how much light transparent, translucent and opaque materials transmit.
- Record a cooling curve from temperature readings taken at regular time intervals.
Variables
An investigation tests how one thing affects another, and the plan starts by naming three kinds of variable.
The independent variable is the one you deliberately change. The dependent variable is the one you measure in response. The control variables are everything else that could affect the result, and they must be kept the same throughout.
Controlling them is what makes the conclusion mean anything. If you investigate how the length of a wire affects its resistance while also using a thicker wire for the longer lengths, any change you see could be caused by either, and the experiment has proved nothing. This is called a fair test, and identifying the control variables is usually worth marks in its own right.
Choose a range for the independent variable wide enough to show a trend, with enough values spread across it, at least five or six, to draw a graph rather than a line between two points.
Worth remembering
- Independent: what you change. Dependent: what you measure. Control: what you keep the same.
- A fair test changes one variable at a time, or the result cannot be attributed to anything.
- Use at least five or six values across a wide enough range to show a trend.
Method
A good method is one another person could follow without asking you anything. Name the apparatus, say what is measured with which instrument, state the values used, and give the steps in order.
Say how many repeats will be taken and that a mean will be calculated, since that reduces the effect of random errors, and say which safety precautions apply and why: eye protection when stretching a wire that may snap, care with hot apparatus, a tray of sand under falling masses.
Plan for good-quality results. Repeating each reading and checking that the repeats agree shows that the results are repeatable; getting similar results with different apparatus or a different method shows that they are reproducible. Keeping every control variable constant, so the experiment really tests the effect of the independent variable, makes it valid. Choosing more precise instruments and a wider range of values improves the results further.
Then say how the results will be handled: what will be plotted against what, and what the gradient or the shape of the line will tell you. A plan that collects data without saying how the data answers the question is incomplete, and this is where many otherwise good plans stop too early.
Practical papers also show apparatus as diagrams, and expect you to recognise it and to draw it. Apparatus is drawn in outline, from the side, as a simple section: a beaker is an open-topped rectangle, a measuring cylinder a tall narrow one with a scale and a pouring lip, a thermometer a thin tube with a bulb at the bottom, and a clamp stand a base, an upright rod and a clamp. Learn to name the common pieces from their outlines, including the newton meter, the metre rule, the stopwatch and the meters and symbols of a circuit.
When you draw apparatus, use a sharp pencil and a ruler for straight edges, keep the parts in proportion and leave out shading and decoration. Label each important part, with a ruled label line that touches the part it names and does not cross other lines, and show where each reading is taken, such as the pointer against the metre rule. Completing a diagram means adding the missing parts, or the missing connections in a circuit, so that the apparatus would actually work.
Worth remembering
- Name the apparatus, the values, the repeats and the safety precautions, so anyone could repeat the method.
- Repeats that agree show repeatability; controlling variables makes the test valid.
- Say what will be plotted and what the graph will show.
- Draw apparatus in pencil as a simple side view, with ruled label lines that touch each part.
Practical contexts
Ray paths through glass or Perspex blocks are traced with optics pins. Put a rectangular block on a sheet of paper and draw round it. Push two pins into the paper on one side, well apart, to mark the incident ray. Looking through the block from the other side, push in two more pins so that they line up exactly with the images of the first two. Remove the block, join the pin marks, draw the ray inside the block, and measure the angles from a normal drawn with a protractor. Placing each pair of pins at least 5 cm apart makes the direction of each ray more accurate.
A semicircular block is used to study total internal reflection. A ray is aimed through the curved side towards the centre of the flat side, so it travels along a radius and does not bend as it enters. As the angle at the flat side is increased, the ray leaving the block bends further from the normal, then grazes along the surface at the critical angle, and beyond that is totally reflected back inside the block.
How much light a material transmits can be tested by shining a lamp through samples of different materials onto a light meter or a screen. A transparent material, such as clear glass, lets almost all the light through, so objects can be seen clearly through it. A translucent material, such as tracing paper or frosted glass, lets some light through but scatters it, so no clear image can be seen. An opaque material, such as card or metal foil, lets no light through. Keep the lamp, its distance and the thickness of each sample the same, so that the material is the only thing that changes.
A cooling curve is recorded by letting a hot liquid cool while reading its temperature at regular time intervals, for example every 30 s or every minute, timed with a stopwatch. Stir before each reading so the temperature is the same throughout, read the thermometer at eye level, record time and temperature in a table, and plot temperature against time. When two containers are compared, keep the starting temperature, the volume of liquid and the surroundings the same. A substance that solidifies as it cools shows a flat section while it changes state.
Worth remembering
- Optics pins: two pins well apart mark each ray; line up the images through the block.
- Transparent materials transmit nearly all light, translucent ones some, opaque ones none.
- Cooling curve: read the temperature at regular time intervals and plot temperature against time.
Worked example
To investigate wire length and resistance, vary length but keep material, cross-sectional area and temperature as constant as practical.
Force–extension investigation
Change a value and watch the readings follow. Open it on the lab stage
Force–extension investigation
3 N stretches the spring by 0.15 m, to 0.35 m long.
- Extension
- 0.15 m
- 3 N ÷ 20 N/m
- Length
- 0.35 m
- 0.2 m + 0.15 m
Goal
Load a spring step by step, find how its extension depends on the load, and find where that stops being true.
Predict, where you are
If Ithe, thewill
Say what you expect before you move anything. Check makes the change for you.
Test, still to come
Change one thing at a time and watch the readings. The notebook keeps a reading each time you record one.
Explain, still to come
After you check a prediction, this says why it happened.
Try this · 0 of 2
- Find the load that stretches a 40 N/m spring by 0.15 m., not yet
- Load the spring past its limit of proportionality. What happens to the graph?, not yet
- Change only the load and record the extension each time. Which setting must stay the same?
force = spring constant × extension
3 N = 20 N/m × 0.15 m
Extension / m
Investigation notebook · 0 readings
Change one variable at a time and record the results. These readings stay here until you leave this lesson or reset the notebook.
About this model
The spring is 0.2 m long unloaded. Every spring here passes its limit of proportionality at 8 N; beyond it, each extra newton stretches it further than the last.
Practice
Warm-up · not marked
Check your understanding
Answer in your own words, then compare with the worked answer. Nothing here is saved or scored.
Worked answer
Independent: the beaker or its insulation. Dependent: temperature at each time. Controls: starting temperature, volume of water and surroundings.
Check your method, units and explanation against it.
Marked practice
Set 1 of 6 · easiest first · Checked as you go, with the worked answer. Sign in or create a free account to save your progress.